When Can You Skip the Cast? A Closer Look at Broken Bones

Black man with a broken arm in a cast
moodboard - stock.adobe
Medically reviewed by
Written by

You've probably heard that broken bones can sometimes heal without a cast. But how does that work? And when is it appropriate to skip the cast? In this blog post, we'll explore the factors that contribute to whether or not a broken bone can heal without a cast. We will also discuss the science behind bone healing and discuss when it is and isn't appropriate to forego using a cast.

How do Broken Bones Heal?

The process of healing a broken bone is complex and gradual, involving different phases that can take weeks or even months to complete. Here is the process our bodies go through to repair a broken bone. 

The Inflammatory Phase 

Man holding inflamed wrist in pain
Prostock-studio - stock.adobe

The first phase of fracture healing is known as the inflammatory phase. This phase begins immediately after the bone has been broken and lasts for approximately 3-5 days. 

During this time, blood vessels in the area are damaged, which causes bleeding. This may result in a bruise forming around the site of the break. The inflammatory phase also involves an influx of immune cells to the area to help clean up the debris from the broken bone and begin the repair process. 

It's important to note that during this time, it's vital to keep the broken bone immobilized so that it can begin to heal properly. Movement can potentially delay or prevent proper healing from occurring. 

The Reparative Phase 

The second phase of fracture healing is known as the reparative phase. This phase begins approximately 1 week after the initial injury and can last anywhere from 4-8 weeks. 

Once again, blood vessels are involved in this stage as they begin to grow into the area around the broken bone (a process known as angiogenesis). These new blood vessels help deliver nutrients and oxygen to the cells working to repair the break. 

In addition, special cells known as osteoblasts begin laying down new bone tissue around the break site. This new tissue helps stabilize and support the broken bone as it continues to heal.  As osteoblasts lay down new bone tissue, they also secrete substances that help promote healing and reduce inflammation. Eventually, this new tissue forms a callus around the broken bone, which further strengthens and supports it. 

If everything goes according to plan, by week 4-8 post-injury, most bones will have healed completely. However, some larger or more complicated breaks may take longer to heal fully. 

The Remodeling Phase 

The final stage of fracture healing is known as remodeling. This stage can last anywhere from several months to 2 years—or longer—depending on the size and location of the break. During this time, your body slowly replaces much of the provisional callus with strong new bone tissue. 

Cast or No cast? 

Female doctor looking at feet x-ray
Mladen - stock.adobe

So now that we know how bones heal, let's talk about when they can heal without a cast. The answer to this question depends on several factors, including: 

Location of the Break 

The location of the break will play a big role in whether or not it will heal without a cast. There are certain bones that are more likely to heal without a cast. They include the collarbone, wrist, and some ankle fractures. These bones have a good blood supply, which helps with healing. Additionally, they are not under as much stress as other bones in the body, so they are less likely to re-break. 

Type of Break 

There are different types of breaks. Some breaks are more likely to heal without a cast than others. A clean break, where the bone ends are still in alignment, is more likely to heal without a cast than a displaced break, where the bone ends are no longer aligned. 


Age can play a role in whether or not a broken bone will heal without a cast. Younger people tend to heal faster than older people. This is because their bones are still growing and have a good blood supply. 


Generally speaking, people who are healthy and do not have any other medical conditions tend to heal faster than people who do not have these things going for them. People who smoke may also have problems with healing because smoking decreases blood flow. 


There can be complications with any injury, and broken bones are no different. If there are complications, it may be necessary to put the broken bone in a cast after all. Some complications that could occur include an infection or problems with the blood supply.

Of course, every injury is different and your doctor will ultimately decide what's best for you. In some cases, even if your broken bone could technically heal without a cast, your doctor may still recommend one to be on the safe side.


In some cases, the doctor may feel that the patient is responsible enough to take care of the injured limb without a cast. This decision is usually based on factors such as the patient's age, occupation, and compliance with instructions. For example, a patient who works in a sedentary job may be able to forego the cast in favor of splints or other forms of support if the injury is minor.

How Casts and Splints Help Broken Bones Heal

Man with broken arm wearing a fiberglass cast
photoguns - stock.adobe

When a bone is broken, it needs time to heal so that the pieces can fuse back together. However, this process can be difficult, as the bone needs to be kept still in order for the healing to occur. Casts and splints are commonly used to immobilize broken bones and promote healing. 

Casts and splints can be uncomfortable and inconvenient, but they are often essential for healing broken bones. By keeping the bone immobilized, they allow the body to focus its energy on repair. While it may be tempting to remove these devices prematurely, it is important to follow your doctor’s instructions for a full and proper recovery.

Dangers of Bone Fractures if Left Untreated

If a fracture is left untreated, the bone may heal in an incorrect position, which can lead to chronic pain and limited mobility. In severe cases, the bone can become necrotic, and the patient may require surgery to correct the injury. Therefore, it is important to seek medical attention as soon as possible after sustaining a fracture. With prompt treatment, the bone will have a better chance of healing properly, and the patient will be able to avoid long-term complications.

Healing Is More Comfortable With Cast21

For people who have suffered a broken bone, the healing process can be extremely painful and frustrating. But with a Cast21 alternative, the recovery process is much easier. Cast21 creates waterproof, breathable, and comfortable alternatives to a cast that are easy to apply and remove. As a result, patients can enjoy the healing process and get back to their normal activities more quickly. Most importantly, Cast21 has been shown to be effective in helping bones heal properly. So if you find yourself in need of a cast, be sure to ask your doctor about Cast21 or contact us today, and we will help you find a provider near you. 

Related Blog Posts

Three kids playing in the snow in a winter forest

Winter Cast Care: 9 Tips for Protecting Your Cast from Snow

January 14, 2024

A man with a blue waterproof cast cover on his forearm is shown in the shower, with water droplets visible, indicating the cast cover is protecting his cast while bathing.

What Happens if a Cast Gets Wet Inside?

December 15, 2023

A medical professional is wrapping a patient's wrist with a white bandage that has red lines along the edges.

Will Swelling Under a Cast Go Away on Its Own? How to Reduce Swelling Under a Cast

November 29, 2023